WayV have often released the strongest music within the NCT universe, including standout singles like Turn Back Time, Take Off and Moonwalk. But, we haven’t had a proper WayV comeback in nearly two years. During that time, members have released solos and sub-units alongside their participation in larger NCT projects. New single Phantom picks up where the group left off, though its dramatic flourishes would benefit from a more compelling set of melodies.
In many ways, Phantom is a classic SM boy group track. Its approach feels angular and even militant at times, anchored by a bombastic chorus with layered vocals and theatrical flourishes buttressing the instrumental. You could throw this song on any EXO album without issue. It’s dark and stylish and performed well. However, there are two major elements that prevent me from absolutely loving this.
First off is the beat, which plods along without any real bite. Compare Phantom to EXO’s Mama – a song with similar tempo and energy. Mama’s percussion slams with delicious intensity. Meanwhile, Phantom’s production feels more canned and reigned in. When it comes to mid-tempo production like this, the beat needs real kick to stand out. Similarly, Phantom’s melodies lack that extra bit of intensity. The chorus – simple as it is – improves with further listens. But, the melodies surrounding it (including a ton of muted grumble-talk) don’t amount to much. They’re pleasant enough — just not very memorable or ear-catching. For a long-awaited comeback, I wanted a bit more. Luckily, WayV sell the song’s charms with their always-polished performance. They remain an underutilized gem in SM Entertainment’s roster.
Hooks 7 Production 8 Longevity 9 Bias 8 RATING 8
